data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/11525/115254237e6c99093e595220c6aa914b0a6c32d0" alt=""
Highlight Hiker Blog
May 9, 2022
Sterling Forest
West Valley Loop
foot traffic only
Well, hello there! Thanks for dropping by! Today I’ve got a nice little loop in Sterling Forest that I’d like to tell you about. I didn’t do this one with my kid, though. That was approved prior to my departure. All I had to say was “There’s climbing involved” and it was BAM! Stamp of approval for me to go it alone.
I was super excited about this loop because it meant I would be able to complete the Lake-to-Lake trail which I began last year. I didn’t….uhhh… however… expect this trail to be so… messy. Wet, sopping mud up to my ankles kind of messy. Poor shoes. They tried. I had to hose them off when I got home. It took a few days for them to dry out and even so, they never quite smelled the same (PU!). But it was messy in kind of a fun way - where you just have to surrender to it because there’s no way to avoid it. Embrace the suck, as they say! Besides, it was a glorious spring day. The temps were high, the sun was out, the spring green was popping out everywhere! What was there to be upset about, really?
I parked at P14 off of East Shore Road in New York and settled in for what felt like a really fast hike. I started sobo on the Lake-to-Lake trail (white blaze), the headed north on the West Valley trail (green blaze), and then brought it all home southwest bound on the Fire Tower trail (red blaze). The slowest portion of the trail was West Valley which skirts a swamp. And in the spring “skirt” means “sits directly on top of”. I imagine in the drier months of the year this trail is really fast and fun with the potential for beaver sightings along the wider portions of Jennings Creek. Speaking of creek, there was creek run off directly across the trail. Scroll down. You’ll see it. I somehow managed to rock hop across but because my shoes were so muddy I was fully prepared to slip off said rock and land in the drink. Poles helped and I proud to say that I managed to keep both feet out of the water!
I saw no one on my loop until I got to the scenic viewpoint along the Fire Tower trail overlooking Greenwood Lake. There was a young couple, lounging in the warm sun and melting off the last of their wintery sorrows. They were really adorable, actually, and very kind to me, letting me obstruct their view for a couple of photos.
And that’s pretty much it. I was very happy and sing-songy and didn’t mind anything that came along the trail because I was just glad spring had officially arrived with purple flowers and green sprouts from every limb of every tree.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/288d8/288d8b1f54c021a0303fc56248d33b9bc0e05434" alt=""
Sterling Forest
West Valley Loop
The P14 parking lot if huge! More than 15 cars could easily fit here, and I'm sure they do on weekends!
The trail head for the west terminus of the Lake-to-Lake trail at P14 off of East Shore Road in New York (which is a lovely drive, BTW)
This is the trail head for the Fire Tower trail. I would end my hike here
A little creek crossing at the start. This is no indication of the hot mess that West Valley would be!
Would you look at that? Sun! Blue Skies! Green in the trees! Flat terrain! =insert romantic sigh here=
Keep a sharp eye out for the trail as it diverges from the woods road to become single track
The single track doesn't last very long, though, and once the trail opens up wide again, it will pretty much be that way for the rest of the loop (with a few exceptions here and there)
I couldn't get enough of the views... spring always bring with it a euphoria, especially after a long cold eastern coast winter
The gate that leads into the heart of Sterling Forest. The map says there is parking here but I have no idea where the woods road would begin. You certainly can't access it from P14!
Oh yes! Much of Sterling Forest allows hunting during certain months of the year. Mostly in the fall. Be sure to wear your hunter orange if you're out and about in the fall during deer, black bear and turkey hunting season. (hunting is strictly prohibited int he Appalachian Trail corridor, and in the Doris Duke Wildlife Preserve.
The very fancy gate
I really wish the deer in this sign would be replaced with an image of a dinosaur! HA!
You know it's spring when you spot a scarlet tanager above you
There are several little off shoot creeks along this end of the Lake-to-Lake trail, all running toward Jennings Hollow (to eventually join the Wanaque River)
Here is another run off creek. I still had no reason to suspect the mess that was to come before me on the West Valley!
Here is where the Lake-to-Lake meets the West Valley (nobo) and my beloved Jennings Hollow trail (sobo)
This is the direction I would head... still clueless
And oh! There it is! The beginning of the end for my shoes!
It was get worse as I got closer to the swamp. This was the easy part!
I thought, at the time, 'That wasn't too bad'
Aaaaaaand then came the swamp. Which looked more like a pond, complete with beaver lodges
It was a very beautiful view, I'll say that much
A little bit cooler here by the water, and a bit more breezy
And just a teensy weensy bit more muddy
But the view!!!
April Showers brings May Mud... I mean! I mean!... FLOWERS.
One last lazy and longing look toward the swamp/pond
The river really did run through it... the trail, that is
And then I thought (chuckles) =stupidly= Oh! Finally! The mud is over! No. No. It wasn't.
Who cares. Damage was already done. And this was pretty and smelled of pine.
The trail wasn't washed out one bit. Nope. Not one tiny bit.
But look at what all that wonderful water does for the flora and fauna!
Up a small hill where the trail was (and would be) dry. THANK GOODNESS. But very clear instructions on where to/where not to go lie ahead.
And then, all of a sudden, Greenwood Lake appears from the scenic view!
Greenwood Lake (looking north)
Greenwood Lake and East Shore Road (looking south)
Greenwood Lake (north. again)
As you may have seen on my Instagram page: I am forever grateful to the Boy Scouts who create these sturdy bridges for we hikers to earn their highest rank of Eagle. You fellows always do such great work!
They deserve a lot of credit. Many bridges are standing for over 15 years!
Like Gregory Miller's bridge! I wonder if he wonders how it's holding up and if anyone ever reads the plaque. I do, Gregory! I always do! Thank you!
It's a good bridge
View looking east from the bridge
View looking west from the bridge
You can always feel when a trail is coming to an end. You know when you're close. And this is that part - you know you're close.
TA DA! The end! Thanks, West Valley Loop! Nice knowing you!